| Páginas no tópico: [1 2] > |
Poll: Which statement best describes translation? Tópico cartaz: ProZ.com Staff
|
|---|
This forum topic is for the discussion of the poll question "Which statement best describes translation?".
This poll was originally submitted by Charlie Smith
View the poll here
A forum topic will appear each time a new pol... See more This forum topic is for the discussion of the poll question "Which statement best describes translation?".
This poll was originally submitted by Charlie Smith
View the poll here
A forum topic will appear each time a new poll is run. For more information, see: http://proz.com/topic/33629 ▲ Collapse
| | | |
| All of the above | May 30, 2008 |
It's an art, etc. that is also what I do for a living.
| | | |
Agnieszka Hayward (X)
Polônia
Local time: 11:24
alemão para polonês
+ ...
Nina Khmielnitzky wrote:
All of the above
This is precisely the answer I miss in this poll
| | | |
Ricardo Pereira 
Portugal
Local time: 10:24
Membro (2006)
inglês para português
+ ...
I also agree that it is a combination of all the options, and then some.
Cheers,
rmpereira
| | |
|
|
|
| All of the above, yes ..... | May 30, 2008 |
Yes it is all of the above +
This subject has been discussed many times before without decisive conclusion (which I doubt exists).
My promosional motto used to be "the one who knows the art and science of translation".
It is a craft if I understand "craft" being a "skill".
It is an art because it takes artistic writing talent to put words into the heart of target language.
It is science because it takes the science of linguistic logics and probability... See more Yes it is all of the above +
This subject has been discussed many times before without decisive conclusion (which I doubt exists).
My promosional motto used to be "the one who knows the art and science of translation".
It is a craft if I understand "craft" being a "skill".
It is an art because it takes artistic writing talent to put words into the heart of target language.
It is science because it takes the science of linguistic logics and probability.
It is an "innate ability" because without it the job would lack quality. If you don't have this vital propensity, you soon be out of business.
And last but not lease, it is a job that needs to be done.
I am very surprise so few answered "it is a science" (so far).
[Edited at 2008-05-30 19:06]
[Edited at 2008-05-30 19:07] ▲ Collapse
| | | |
Maria Castro
Portugal
Local time: 10:24
Membro (2008)
inglês para português
+ ...
MODERADOR SITE LOCALIZER | all of the above | May 30, 2008 |
all of the above, absolutely...
humbird summarises the reasons why very well and I totally agree with her.
I think this option should have been included in the poll.
| | | |
| One thing is missing | May 30, 2008 |
I agree with most of the colleagues' comments, but I think that translation is also a profession.
Have a nice weekend,
Fernando
[Edited at 2008-05-30 20:09]
| | | |
Charlie Smith (X)
Reino Unido
Local time: 10:24
grego para inglês
| An interesting discussion… | May 30, 2008 |
I’m sure this is a discussion that actually has no likelihood of ascertaining a definite answer, but I was curious as to what people had to say on the matter. Also I did not include the ‘all of the above’ option as I am interested not in a concrete definition (as has been already said translation is in fact a mixture) but more to which ‘processes’ your perception of what you do tends towards.
My answer would be: a craft (of course as I understand the term)
... See more I’m sure this is a discussion that actually has no likelihood of ascertaining a definite answer, but I was curious as to what people had to say on the matter. Also I did not include the ‘all of the above’ option as I am interested not in a concrete definition (as has been already said translation is in fact a mixture) but more to which ‘processes’ your perception of what you do tends towards.
My answer would be: a craft (of course as I understand the term)
Translation is less like a science as nothing is absolute and there are rules but they are often flexible and sometimes totally wrong for a certain translation – also if it were more of a science machine translation would be a more effective practical process as opposed to a means to entertain translators with its hilarious outcomes. Art, as I see it, on the other hand is more of a free creative process and I feel the bind we have to remain close to the original distances translation from an art form. As for an innate ability, which is of course a factor, even those not disposed towards translation - which could be a description of those with no ‘innate ability’ - can be taught the principals, and trained in it and be able to produce a passable translation.
It is a creative process which is at the same time restricted in its creation by it utilitarianism, each translation we produce can be beautiful and even awe inspiring yet it is judged not only on its aesthetics but on its ability to perform it function, all of which lead me to think of it as a craft. ▲ Collapse
| | |
|
|
|
mediamatrix (X)
Local time: 05:24
espanhol para inglês
+ ...
| Translation: A necessary evil in the global economy | May 30, 2008 |
As one who is far happier earning money from the divulgation of his own thoughts rather than 'merely' expressing someone else's thoughts in a different language, I can find little in translation that merits the use of the qualifier 'best', as in 'best describes translation'.
Most of what I now translate was written by me anyway, so the source texts are well-nigh perfect . I very rarely have doubts as to what the autho... See more As one who is far happier earning money from the divulgation of his own thoughts rather than 'merely' expressing someone else's thoughts in a different language, I can find little in translation that merits the use of the qualifier 'best', as in 'best describes translation'.
Most of what I now translate was written by me anyway, so the source texts are well-nigh perfect . I very rarely have doubts as to what the author was trying to say in his source text - and if I do have doubts, then I simply rewrite my source text or delete the sentence altogether!
So, I have two 'other' replies:
- translation is a necessary evil in the global economy;
- translation is a doddle.
I used to have a T-shirt inscribed with the words: Art is dirty work - but somebody's got to do it! Much the same could be said for translation.
MediaMatrix ▲ Collapse
| | | |
lorette
França
Local time: 11:24
alemão para francês
+ ...
| A mix + other! | May 31, 2008 |
It is a daily challenge
[Edited at 2008-05-31 09:00]
| | | |
Miet Ooms
Bélgica
Local time: 11:24
alemão para holandês
+ ...
| All of the above ! | May 31, 2008 |
and more...
| | | |
| Innate ability | May 31, 2008 |
I fully agree with Charlie, translation is neither science nor art. For me, it's more of an innate ability, although I was a bit torn between innate ability and craft (just a bit though)
| | |
|
|
|
| TRANSLATION IS... | May 31, 2008 |
Translation is Science, a Skill, an Art and a matter of good Taste
| | | |
neilmac
Espanha
Local time: 11:24
espanhol para inglês
+ ...
on whether you understand the principles of utilitarianism ... or not
| | | |
| Mainly an Art | May 31, 2008 |
A good translator needs to be a good writer, and writing is an art
[Edited at 2008-05-31 19:37]
| | | |
| Páginas no tópico: [1 2] > |
Login to reply/comment 
